Yes, there are risks in applying that you should discuss with your legal advisor.
Your case can be denied if you fail to prove the minimum requirements. Additionally, cases are decided on a case-by-case basis. If you are in removal proceedings or have an outstanding removal order, this makes your case much more complex, but you are not necessarily ineligible. The USCIS FAQs do list the circumstances when you cannot apply for PIP, so if you have bad facts in your case other than unlawful entry, you should review your case with legal counsel.
PIP is a discretionary form of relief, and there is no avenue to adjudicate or appeal if your application is denied.
Legal Challenges to PIP: It is expected that anti-immigration groups will sue to block this program, and a judge could decide to end parole in place. The impact on your case would depend upon where you are in the process. Follow the USCIS website for updates.
The next president could decide to terminate the program. This could impact your case if you haven’t filed by then or if your case is pending. It’s unknown whether it would impact your case if you have a pending adjustment of status case based on a prior approved PIP.
Unlawful Presence Waiver Application: If you have a or approved I-601A unlawful presence waiver, you can file for PIP. However, once you file for adjustment, your I-601A waiver will be terminated. Be sure to discuss the best strategy with your legal advisor before taking action.
Tip: USCIS has been sending emails or texts to current applicants and beneficiaries of I-601A waivers to let them know to consider this program in the alternative. Be sure to seek legal advice about your situation. Also, follow the USCIS website and FAQs for the latest information.
Travel after PIP Approval: Parole terminates automatically if you leave the United States.
Termination of Parole: Parole may also be terminated at any time at the discretion of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) if USCIS decides parole is no longer justified. For example, if you commit a crime while on parole or USCIS discovers you lied in the application, your parole could be revoked.
Immigration Enforcement: DHS usually won’t use the information you give them to start immigration enforcement unless they think you are a danger to the country or other people. However, DHS can still take action, even if you are waiting for permission to stay in the country. DHS might share your information with other security or law enforcement agencies to help with things like checking your request, stopping fake claims, or investigating crimes.
The Guidelines for the Enforcement of Civil Immigration Law direct DHS to focus its resources on noncitizens who pose a threat to national security, public safety, or border security. Those guidelines are still in effect. Meeting the PIP requirements or filing a request under this process does not prevent enforcement action against someone when it is appropriate under the law.
If your case is denied, DHS must follow the guidelines above to decide whether to put someone in deportation or removal proceedings. However, there is an exception for stepchildren who entered the United States unlawfully after November 1, 2020 and who otherwise meet the criteria for PIP.